Israel unlikely to be impacted by Dubai crisis
www.chinaview.cn 2009-12-07 20:12:18   Print

    by Zhang Yanyang

    JERUSALEM, Dec. 7 (Xinhua) -- The Dubai crisis should serve as an eye opener to countries that are too leveraged, said Israeli economists, noting that Israel's continued productivity in the high-tech sector, strict budget policy and banking regulation would mostly shield it from ongoing fluctuation in the world market.

    "Those countries that took overly high leverage are going to suffer," Shlomo Maoz, chief economist at Excellence Nessuah told Xinhua, adding that there were many other overly leveraged markets which were likely to crash and lead to the continued fluctuation of the world market in the near future.

    In Maoz's opinion, Dubai was only one example of the overly high leverage that some countries and firms assumed, and the banking system in Greece and Turkey as well as in Hungary and other countries in eastern Europe were also too leveraged, allowing for investments with little to no money down.

    "As long as the key lending rate of the U.S. dollar is zero, the appetite for taking risk will increase. And companies will continue to take risk though it might come at a very high cost," Maoz said.

    While the subprime mortgage crisis originated with home owners who were too leveraged as they had put little to no money down, thereby inflating the real estate sector, government policies aimed at stimulating the recovery from the financial crisis have also fueled the creation of bubbles.

    In order to facilitate the recovery from the global crisis, many governments injected large amounts of money in the economy and cut interest rates in the hopes of increasing liquidity and consumer spending.

    However, this "cheap money" fueled the creation of new bubbles as it is unclear how justified price levels are when the alternative is investment at zero interest, analysts said.

    "I think what the world is learning is that risk premiums were reflecting a sort of bubble situation over the past few months that spread pretty much across the board," Jonathan Katz, an economist at HSBC told Xinhua.

    "Sovereign and corporate spreads came down rapidly and Dubai is sort of an awakener in that countries have to be looked at separately and there is risk out there and perhaps more than we are factoring in," said Katz.

    Katz noted that countries like Greece and Spain were among those who were considered problematic when it comes to their debt level. Those countries reacted negatively to what happened in Dubai because their own situation is also worrisome with a high debt increase of as much as 120 percent of GDP and a double-digit fiscal deficit.

    The analysts said that Israel is recorded as a very save and defensive player in today's market, noting that investors differentiated the stronger emerging market economies from the more leveraged economies during times of financial turmoil and uncertainty.

    Israel's strength is largely rooted in its fiscal discipline. Under the guidance of Bank of Israel governor Stanley Fischer, fiscal planning for 2009 and 2010 has involved a radical program including higher taxes and a cap on the fiscal deficit at 6 percent of GDP to try and contain an already high level of public debt to GDP rather than allowing it to climb further like in other countries.

    In addition, Israel also boasts a very large productive sector in manufacturing of high-tech products, a large current account surplus for the sixth consecutive year, low government debt, and tight regulation on commercial banks.

    While Israel's fiscal policy, macroeconomic fundamentals, and high-tech productivity have helped shield it from much of the financial tremors that have shocked the world, its lack of ties to countries like United Arab Emirates also plays a role.

    "Our ties are limited, mainly due to the fact that our economic ties are limited to the Arab world in general," Inon Dafni, chief economist at Israel Discount Bank told Xinhua.

    Analysts noted that any fear of there being a domino effect on other markets and through that an indirect impact on Israel also seemed unlikely.

    "We perceive the Dubai effect as smaller than the newspapers make believe," Ayelet Nir, chief economist at IBI told Xinhua. "The impact of the Dubai effect on the global economy is already diminishing."

    She noted that people should learn from the case of Dubai that guarantees for any money one invests are as important as the investment itself.

    People invested in all kinds of real estate projects in Dubai and did not take into consideration the risk of the investment. Investors failed to consider who would use all the real estate projects in the end and the volume of projects was simply too large for the country.

    "The lesson here is that one should always ask whether the project is on track to fulfill its target. The real estate projects in Dubai were very attractive, but they came with a huge risk and I don't think people took that risk into consideration," Nir said.

Editor: Deng Shasha
Related Stories
Dubai crisis rings bells of prudent investment
Israeli expert says Dubai-style crash highly unlikely in China
News Analysis: Israeli analysts say Dubai's crisis to have limited global impact
Home World
  Back to Top