by Matthew Rusling
WASHINGTON, Aug. 17 (Xinhua) -- A rash of economic indicators show early
signs of recovery from the worst U.S. recession in decades, but the economy
could still take another nose dive, economists said.
Gross domestic product for the second quarter of this year shrank by only 1
percent in the U.S., with auto sales rising 15 percent in July and manufacturers
reporting rapid growth in new orders.
Moreover, the S&P/Case-Shiller 20-city index of home prices rose 0.5
percent for the three-month period that ended in May. A more stable housing
market would boost the flow of credit and reduce loan defaults, experts said.
Based on those and other positive figures, economists believe the recession
will soon reach -- or has already hit -- its bottom. But despite the welcome
news, some fret the rebound will be short lived.
Tad DeHaven, budget analyst at the Washington, D.C.-based CATO Institute,
said that while the economy might rebound, gains could be lackluster and
temporary.
"We'll either get a shallow recovery and meander along or have a recovery
followed by another recession," he said.
The problem, he said, is that government spending has triggered much of the
recent growth, and that is no panacea for long-term growth.
Programs such as "cash for clunkers" -- a government-funded program
encouraging people to purchase new cars while trading in old ones -- may boost
auto sales in the short term but could run out of gas once funds dry up.
"Car sales are up because of 'cash for clunkers'," he said. "Soyou get the
jump in auto sales but it's just short term."
Moreover, the economy faces a number of issues that could bode ill for the
country's long-term fiscal health, such as skyrocketing deficits and too much
borrowing, he said. "The government can not continue to issue the debt that it
is issuing," he warned.
And if government spending is a cure-all for sick economies, "then
shouldn't we have been in an economic boom now?" Former President George W. Bush
oversaw eight years of heavy government spending that yielded few economic
benefits, he said.
Desmond Lachman, resident fellow at the Washington, D.C.-based American
Enterprise Institute, said the numbers indicated that the pace of economic
decline had moderated substantially. "So we are going to get a bounce in the
third quarter," he said.
Companies' inventories are depleting -- which means production must ramp up
-- "cash for clunkers" is boosting auto sales and the stimulus package is
kicking in, all of which will stabilize the economy in the short run, he said.
"But the issue is whether it will continue," he said, adding that there are
a number of reasons to be cautious.
Those include retail sales, which declined in July, compressed wages and
the possibility that unemployment could linger around the 10 percent mark until
2010, he said. And with consumption fueling 70 percent of demand, such
conditions bode ill for the long term.
Moreover, the unemployed may feel the sting of joblessness for some time,
as companies will increase hours for part-timers before hiring new employees, he
said.
And while GDP is projected to rise by 2 or 3 percent this quarter, it will
take time to climb to pre-recession levels, Lachman said.
Dean Baker, co-director at the Washington, D.C.- based Center for Economic
and Policy Research, said, "I really haven't been that impressed with any
(numbers) we've seen."
Investment and net exports will be the drivers that lift the economy out of
recession, but there is no evidence that those indicators are picking up, he
said. Unemployment will continue to weaken the market, given that the jobless
tend to spend less, he said.
Indeed, Chad Stone, chief economist at the Washington, D.C.-based Center on
Budget and Policy Priorities, said July's employment report showed that labor
market conditions remained "extremely harsh for job-seekers, generating a record
level of long-term unemployment".
But the good news is that the labor market has improved from earlier this
year, signaling that a rebound may be in sight, although "that news must be
tempered by the ongoing plight of the long-term unemployed," he said.
Other experts, however, voiced a more positive outlook and pointed to
indicators that could signal a turnaround. Most important are the
higher-than-usual industrial productivity figures that could bode well for the
short term and provide the spark that re-ignites the economy.
"I'm optimistic that we are on the road to recovery," said Robert Johnson,
associate director of economic analysis at Morning star, an independent research
provider. He added the economy had hit bottom in June or July and that growing
manufacturing orders could spark a ripple effect to other sectors.
Since many company inventories are low, firms will need to ramp up orders
from factories. That will put more people to work and spark an uptick in
spending, he said.
"Exact predictions are difficult, and any unwise decisions in Washington
could thwart a rebound, but based on numbers I've seen so far we'll have a shot
at 3 percent long-term growth," Johnson said.
France and Germany's recent GDP increases could also be good for U.S.
exports, he said. "If you put all those things together it's a roadmap to
recovery."