By Jaime Lopez Castaneda, Alexander Manda
MEXICO CITY, July 2 (Xinhua) -- Mexico's urgent need to fix its fiscal
problems is the clearest lesson from the world economic crisis hitting home
here, Raul Feliz, an expert from the prestigious state-run Economic Research and
Teaching center (CIDE), told Xinhua in an interview.
"We have to put our house in order first," said Feliz. "We have been
treating water, taking advantage of the cyclical high price of oil, and the
crisis has exposed our weak fiscal position," he said.
On Tuesday, Mexico's Finance Ministry reported a 24 percent decline in oil
revenue in the year to May, compared with the same period a year earlier. Oil
accounted for around 40 percent of state earnings.
Tax earnings, at 489 billion pesos (37.6 billion dollars), were 15 percent
lower compared with the same period a year earlier. Value added tax (VAT) fell
20 percent, income tax 17.4 percent and the flat rate business tax 4.1 percent.
In addition, the government estimated it would lose some 465 billion pesos
(35.7 billion dollars) in earnings, equivalent to 3.9 percent of gross domestic
product (GDP), in 2009 because of one-off measures, like tax moratoriums for
those who suffered the nation's flu crisis. In 2010 this figure will rise to
some 503 billion pesos (38.6 billion dollars), nearly 4 percent of GDP.
In May, Mexico had a budget deficit of 10 billion pesos (769.2 million
dollars).
SLUMPING TRADE
Oil exports represent a significant source of volatility for international
trade too, according to data published by the National Statistics and Geography
Agency (Inegi). In May, oil exports fell 52.1 percent, while non-oil exports
fell 28.2 percent. Overall May trade reached 17.47 billion dollars, down 32.8
percent from a year earlier.
The steepest declines in manufactured goods exports were from steel, with
59.1 percent, and autos, with 42.7 percent. Agricultural goods and fishing
exports were only 4.6 percent lower, at 708 million dollars.
Even so, wheat exports posted a fall of 47.3 percent, grapes and raisins
fell by 30.8 percent and tomatoes fell by 15.4 percent. Imports were worth 16.8
billion dollars, falling 35.5 percent in May from a year earlier.
The Inegi also said that employment in Mexico's intermediate goods industry
had fallen 8.4 percent from a year earlier, with production workers worst hit,
largely due to a steep decline in trade with the United States, purchaser of
around 80 percent of the nation's exports.
WAITING FOR U.S. RECOVERY
Being tied so closely to the United States means that Mexico has no other
option but to wait for its neighbor to recover, so that it can exit the crisis,
Feliz said.
"I don't like it, but it is the truth," he said. "Mexico is a comparatively
small economy closely linked to the world economy and especially to the U.S.
economy," he said. "We don't have internal drivers that are strong enough to
ensure our economy takes off independently of the United States."
According to Eric Rosengren, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank in
the northern U.S. city of Boston, the United States will start to recover during
the second half of 2009, but unemployment will continue to rise there until
early 2010.
Since the U.S. recession began in December 2007, its economy has lost 6
million jobs and the current 9.4 percent unemployment rate is the highest since
1984.
On Monday, the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago reported its economic
activity index at -2.3, more negative than April's -2.27. The production segment
posted a level of -0.65 compared with -0.47 in April.
BIG DILEMMA
Faced with this difficult situation, analysts predict that the Mexican
government will seek to make the tax system more efficient and, as opposition
leader Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador warns, seek to impose VAT on food and
medicine.
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, which is
forecasting that Mexico's GDP will contract 8 percent this year, called on the
government not to rush into "fiscal consolidation" for fear that it may extend
the recession.
Echoing this, Gerardo Aparicio, an economist with the privately-owned
Panamericana University, warned that it could be discouraging for those that pay
their taxes.
Feliz warned that the money that is being spent represents around 1 percent
of GDP and is not enough to turn around the current crisis.
"If instead of 1 or 1.5 percent of GDP we were to have 20 percent, our
ability to respond would be much higher," he said.
"What we have seen is next to no ability to compensate for the U.S. cycle.
In reality, Mexico did not have any ability to uncouple from what was happening
in the United States," he said.
Feliz urged Mexican businesses to develop new overseas markets in order to
diversify their export base and develop stronger domestic financial markets.
"Our financial market showed that it could not dissociate. It is neither big
enough nor diverse enough."
Mexico would continue to be a very open economy and stay closely connected
to the United States, but there will be much to do to ensure the Latin American
nation is not so affected by the crisis that erupted in its powerful neighbor,
he said.
Special Report: Global Financial Crisis
