BEIJING, Feb. 12 (Xinhua) -- Auction giant Christie's has denied a possible
private sale of two Chinese relics, saying that the auction will go on as
scheduled despite criticism from China.
In an e-mail to Xinhua, Christie's responded to reports in Taiwan's
Economic Daily newspaper and the European Journal, a television program, which
said Christie's would conduct a private sale of the Yuanmingyuan rabbit and rat
head sculptures.
The auction house said the reports "are not true."
The two items, the Qing Dynasty (1644-1911) bronze rabbit and rat head
sculptures, will be auctioned by Christie's in Paris from Feb. 23 to 25.
The sculptures currently belong to the Pierre Berge-Yves Saint Laurent
(YSL) Foundation and were put up for auction by Pierre Berge. They were expected
to fetch 8 million to 10 million euros (about 10.4 million to 13 million U.S.
dollars) each.
"The YSL collection holds firm legal title to the heads and so we
respectfully believe the auction will proceed," the auction house said in the
e-mail.
STOLEN FROM SUMMER PALACE
The two bronze head sculptures were housed in Yuanmingyuan, Beijing's
Imperial Summer Palace. They were stolen when the palace was burned down by
Anglo-French allied forces during the Second Opium War in 1860.
Christie's carried a detailed description of the two bronzes on its
website, saying that the two formed part of the zodiacal clepsydra (water clock)
that decorated the Calm Sea Pavilion in the Old Summer Palace of Emperor
Qianlong (1736-1795).
"Constructed between 1756 and 1759 under the supervision of the famous
Jesuit priest Giuseppe Castiglione, the heads are characterized by a distinctly
Western style," Mathilde Courteault, head of the company's Asian Department, was
quoted by the website as saying.
Christie's announcement that it would auction the two relics aroused
concern in China, with many online forums flooded with angry demands for the
objects' return.
A team of 81 Chinese lawyers has written to Christie's in an effort to stop
the sale.
Liu Yang, one of the lawyers working on the case, was unavailable to
comment Thursday, but he told Xinhua Tuesday that they hoped Christie's could
reconsider the sale of the relics, withdraw them from auction and persuade the
owner to return them to China. Liu said the lawyers had also written to Berge,
asking him not to auction the relics and return them to China.
He said his team would sue Berge if there was no "positive feedback from
them (Pierre Berge and Christie's) within a reasonable period."
Christie's would be involved in the lawsuit as the third party. But he
declined to say how long his team would wait for the "positive feedback."
Christie's public relations officer in China, Chen Yan, confirmed that the
company's Beijing office had received the letter.
Li Xingfeng, another lawyer on the attorney team, told Xinhua Thursday that
so far they have not received a clear reply from the auction house. Li said: "If
Christie's proceeds with the auction, we will take further legal measures in
France."
LEGAL TEAM'S OBSTACLES
Since they joined forces last month, the attorney team has experienced
several twists and turns in their attempt to return the relics to China. Their
endeavor was halted until they found the Aisin Gioro family clansman
association, representing descendants of Qing Dynasty-era Manchu royalty. This
clan was the only group that, under French law, was qualified to bring suit as
the plaintiffs.
The team faced other trouble: finding someone to foot the bill. They
eventually found a real estate company that asked not to be identified. It
promised to donate 400,000 yuan (about 58,000 U.S. dollars) to the plan.
"No matter what the result is, we have seen great concern shown by Chinese
people, and the case raised their awareness of protecting national treasures by
adopting legal measures," said Li.
China and France signed the 1995 Unidroit Convention on Stolen or Illegally
Exported Cultural Objects, which stipulated that any cultural object looted or
lost during war, regardless of how long ago, should be returned.
China's State Administration of Cultural Heritage (SACH) said last month
that Christie's auction of the relics was unacceptable and China would not try
to buy them back.
Song Xinchao, director of the museum department with the SACH, said the
best way to deal with the issue was to ignore it, because some business people
might exploit the patriotic concerns of the Chinese people to raise bidding
prices for their own monetary gain.
The American auction house Sotheby's tried to put a bronze horse head up
for auction in 2007. But Macao billionaire Stanley Ho pre-empted the auction by
purchasing the relic for 69.1 million Hong Kong dollars (about 9 million U.S.
dollars), and he donated it to the Chinese government.
So far, five of the 12 bronze animal heads have been returned to China. The
whereabouts of five others are unknown.