XINHUA online
 Breaking News Heavy fighting leaves 15 dead in S. Afghanistan    Urgent: American teenager injured in Tel Aviv bombing dies    Urgent: American teenager injured in Tel Aviv bombing dies    Urgent: 2 British soldiers killed in Iraq     Tour bus accident kills 1, injures 6 in Thailand    Urgent: 15 feared dead in Indonesian sand-mining accident     
  About China
  CPC & Other Parties
  State Organs
  Local Leadership
  White Papers
  Major Projects
  English Websites
- Conferences & Exhibitions
- Investment
- Bidding
- Enterprises
- Policy update
- Technological & Economic Development Zones
Online marketplace of Manufacturers & Wholesalers
   News Photos Voice People BizChina Feature About us   
U.S. Justice Department urges end to AT&T suit
www.chinaview.cn 2006-05-15 01:30:46

    LOS ANGELES, May 14 (Xinhua) -- The U.S. Justice Department hascalled for an end to an eavesdropping lawsuit against AT&T Corp., citing possible damage from the litigation to national security, the Los Angeles Times reported on Sunday.

    The call won the support from John D. Negroponte, director of national intelligence, and from Lt. Gen. Keith B. Alexander, director of the National Security Agency (NSA), according to the paper.

    It quoted officials as saying that the lawsuit by AT&T customers would bring up matters too sensitive for public discussion.

    The lawsuit was brought up in San Francisco after press reportsshowed that the NSA had access to domestic calling records from three of the four major telephone companies including AT&T since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. The NSA interception of international phone calls was described by the Bush Administrationas the country's most highly classified spy project.

    A number of legal experts said the program appeared to violate privacy laws and restrictions on spying within U.S. borders.

    The San Francisco case dates from earlier reports, including accounts that the NSA listened in on phone calls with one end in the United States, and that the agency was conducting widespread data-mining, scanning the activities of phone company customers insearch of patterns or connections to terrorists.

    None of the activities were approved by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, which was established in 1978 to secretly authorize taps on the communications of suspected foreignagents on U.S. soil.

    The administration was attempting to avoid congressional and public debates on the details of the NSA's controversial surveillance activities since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

    Referring to the case, Negroponte and Alexander said they couldneither confirm nor deny specific allegations without risking the disclosure of secret methods.

    In the new court papers, Justice Department officials argued that whether the operations were legal or not, they involved secrets.

    "Adjudication of whether the alleged surveillance activities have been conducted within lawful authority cannot be resolved without state secrets," wrote Assistant Atty. Gen. Peter D. Keisler and other lawyers on the case.

    But customers in the lawsuit said privacy and laws cannot be sacrificed under the cloak of national security.

    "The government is trying to shove the NSA and AT&T illegal spying operation under an impenetrable cloak of secrecy," said Kevin Bankston of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a civil liberties group representing AT&T customers in the lawsuit. "They are essentially arguing that no one can ever go to court to stop illegal surveillance, so long as they claim it was done in the name of national security."

    Bankston said that the essentials of the spying program had been widely reported, so that no real secrets would be revealed.

    But law experts said the lawsuit against AT&T was unlikely to succeed since many previous court challenges had been derailed by the national security argument, known formally as the state secrets privilege.

    The government was not originally a party to the case, which instead seeks to hold AT&T responsible for divulging private information to the NSA. Now that it has joined the fight, it couldpresent insurmountable obstacles, law experts said. Enditem


Editor: Wang Nan
  Related Story  
Copyright ©2003 Xinhua News Agency. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.