|
BEIJING, Feb. 28 -- A determined Shanghai man
who has spent the last eight years challenging the authority of the country's
most popular reference book is suing one of its distributors.
Chen Dingxiang and Shanghai Book Mall have already
attended a preliminary hearing yesterday at Shanghai Huangpu District People's
Court. A full hearing date has yet to be arranged.
The 56-year-old is asking the mall to stop selling
Xinhua Dictionary, alleging it is riddled with errors, refund him twice the
amount he spent on the book, make an apology in national media and pay him
compensation of 20,000 yuan (US$2,470).
According to his indictment, the 10th edition of
Xinhua Dictionary he bought in July last year has more than 4,000 definitions or
usages either wrong or inaccurate.
"The book, of poor quality, not only violates
consumer rights and interests, but also causes damage to their knowledge," said
Chen's lawyer Ye Han.
At least 400 million copies of the book have been
sold since it was first launched.
Ye declined to reveal why Chen was suing the mall
instead of the book's publisher, Commercial Press. "Chen chose a smart way," she
said.
Chen began to doubt the accuracy of the book as early
as 1998 when his daughter raised a question about one entry.
He said he disagreed with the use of a noun and an
adjective in one definition.
Two months later Chen read two national newspaper
reports that described the book as "perfect," without even one mistake. He
doubted the claims and started the eight-year-long fault finding mission.
To concentrate on the task, Chen quit his job as a
deputy general manager at a Guangdong enterprise.
He studied every character in the dictionary
carefully and in the first five years he spent up to 18 hours a day on the
project.
In 2001, Chen finished his first book discussing
faults he found in three of the most popular dictionaries in the country,
including Xinhua Dictionary, and sent it to Commercial Press. He got no
response, and was later told the manuscript had been lost.
Chen claimed that some of his suggestions were later
adopted in a new edition of one of the books.
He finished another book focusing solely on Xinhua
Dictionary in 2004, which he sent on, and four months later the book was sent
back.
Fu Minrong, the mall's attorney, argued that the book
was a licensed publication and that what Chen claimed as inaccurate was
baseless.
(Source: China Daily) |